
by: Simone St. James
published: January 20, 2026
genre: Horror, Mystery, Thriller
344 pages, E-Book
Goodreads | Amazon

Goodreads Summary
Siblings return to the house they fled eighteen years before, called back by the ghost of their long-missing brother and his haunting request to come home.
Strange things happen in Fell, New York: A mysterious drowning at the town’s roadside motel. The unexplained death of a young girl whose body is left by the railroad tracks. For Violet, Vail, and Dodie Esmie the final straw was their little brother’s shocking disappearance, which started as a normal game of hide-and-seek.
As their parents grew increasingly distant, the sisters were each haunted by visions and frightening events, leading them to leave town and never look back. Violet still sees dead people—spirits who remind her of Sister, the menacing presence that terrorized her for years. Now after nearly two decades it’s time for a homecoming—because Ben is back, and he’s ready to lead them to the answers they’ve longed for and long feared.
Character Summary
Set in 1989, A Box Full of Darkness follows the three Esmie siblings, each haunted in their own way by a troubled childhood in Fell and the home they swore to leave behind.
Violet, the eldest, has been plagued by her ability to see the dead since childhood, leaving her an outsider whose struggles with friendships and relationships have followed her into adulthood. Now recovering from a bitter divorce and custody battle, an unsettling phone call forces her to confront the home she fled at seventeen and vowed never to return to.
Vail, the middle child, has spent his adult life chasing UFO sightings and alien encounters, hoping to make sense of the nightmares and memories that continue to haunt him. A loner who struggles with personal connections, he nevertheless answers Violet’s call without hesitation.
Dodie, the youngest, has built a successful niche modeling career in New York City, putting as much distance as possible between herself and Fell. Just as she’s beginning a promising relationship with someone who embraces her eccentricities, she’s summoned back to the place she’s worked so hard to forget.
Despite their different paths, all three share the scars of a dysfunctional upbringing: a father who vanished without a trace and a mother whose alcoholism ultimately claimed her life. Their relationships with their parents were so fractured that none felt compelled to properly lay their mother’s ashes to rest.
Now, years after escaping Fell, the siblings find themselves drawn back to the childhood home that shaped them, each carrying their own version of the darkness they’ve spent a lifetime trying to outrun.
My Thoughts
I barely liked this book, so I’ll start with the few things I actually enjoyed.
St. James has a very descriptive writing style. It’s occasionally wordy, but her prose is easy to follow and engaging enough that I finished the book in a single day. Having also read The Sun Down Motel, I’ve noticed her penchant for the supernatural, and I’m beginning to think she has a habit of forcing it into stories that don’t necessarily need it. A Box Full of Darkness had all the makings of a compelling serial killer thriller or a solid murder mystery, but the supernatural elements felt forced, and the eventual plot twist was simply too far-fetched for me.
I love a good ghost story, but the horror here was disappointingly underwhelming. For a book that spends so much time building tension and revisiting the unsettling history of Fell, the final climax was surprisingly clunky and rushed. We spend nearly the entire novel unraveling the mysteries surrounding this town and the Esmie family, only for everything to come to a head in what feels like a matter of minutes. The resolution lacked the depth and payoff the story desperately needed, leaving me more confused than satisfied.
And then there are the characters. Not a single one had enough redeeming qualities to make me genuinely care about what happened to them.
Violet is so consumed by her visions that there seems to be little else to her personality. Her awkward, sarcastic banter with Bradley Pine, a high school crush she hasn’t seen in twenty years, adds very little to the story. Bradley himself is crass, with a personality that seems to rely entirely on sarcasm to disguise the fact that he’s rather unlikable. But hey, to each their own.
Vail, meanwhile, is just… there. His chapters often feel repetitive, particularly his endless reflections on being “It” during childhood games of hide-and-seek with his siblings. We get it! What initially seemed like an interesting piece of childhood trauma quickly became an overused detail that did little to develop his character.
And finally, Dodie. First of all, where did that name even come from? She’s the stereotypical younger sister: smart-mouthed, sassy, and seemingly written to deliver attitude rather than substance. Beneath all that sass is a surprisingly shallow character, saddled with yet another unnecessary romantic subplot that contributes virtually nothing to the story’s progression.
Ultimately, A Box Full of Darkness had an intriguing premise and enough atmosphere to keep me turning the pages, but it never quite delivered on its potential. The supernatural elements felt misplaced, the characters lacked depth, and the rushed conclusion undermined much of the suspense the novel worked so hard to establish. It was a quick read, but unfortunately, not a particularly satisfying one.








Leave a Reply